BillMyWeek How it worksGuidesFree toolsLog inSign up

What to do when a client disputes your invoice

Getting paid · Published 9 November 2026 · Updated 26 October 2026 · 5 min read

A client who says 'I'm not paying that' is different from one who simply pays late. Usually only part of the invoice is in question: a day they say you weren't there, some overtime, a snag. Handled calmly and in writing, most disputes get settled in days. Here's a step-by-step way to deal with one.

Make your invoice in a minute

Try it freeMake an invoice now, no sign-up. Then 14 days free, then £1.99 a month or £19.99 a year.Trade invoice templates: find yours
On this page
  1. First, reply quickly and in writing
  2. Work out what kind of dispute it is
  3. Ask for the undisputed part now
  4. If they're right, fix it properly
  5. If you think they're wrong
  6. If the client is a homeowner
  7. If you can't agree
  8. Preventing the next one

Checked against GOV.UK and legislation.gov.uk on 26 October 2026. General information for England and Wales, not legal advice.

First, reply quickly and in writing

Reply the same day if you can, by email so there's a record. Stay factual. Thank them for raising it, say you'll look into it, and ask them to tell you in writing exactly which lines they dispute and why. A dispute that's specific can be solved. "I'm not happy with it" can't.

Don't stop at the phone call. If you agree something by phone, follow it up with a short email: "As discussed, you're happy with everything except Sunday's hours, which you'll check with the site manager by Friday."

Work out what kind of dispute it is

What they sayWhat usually helps
"You weren't on site that day" or "the hours are wrong"Timesheets, site sign-in records, messages from that day, photos with dates
"We never agreed that rate" or "overtime wasn't agreed"Your quote, rate card or the email where the rate was agreed
"The work isn't finished" or "there's a defect"Photos, the scope of work, an offer to come back and put it right
"We didn't order those materials"Receipts, delivery notes, the message asking for them
"The invoice is wrong" (name, PO number, VAT)Usually admin: correct it and reissue

Many "disputes" are admin problems in disguise: a missing purchase order number or the wrong company name. Check those first; our chasing guide has a list.

Ask for the undisputed part now

If only part of the invoice is in question, ask them to pay the rest by the due date while you sort out the disputed bit. It's a reasonable request and most clients will agree.

Example: your weekly invoice is £1,150.00: 5 days at £200 (£1,000.00) and 4 hours' Sunday work at £37.50 an hour (£150.00). The client disputes only the Sunday hours. Ask them to pay £1,000.00 now. Only £150.00 is left to discuss, and your cash flow doesn't stop over a small amount. The figures are only an example.

For business clients, if they don't pay the undisputed part on time, GOV.UK's late payment rules on statutory interest and recovery costs can apply to that late payment. You can work out the figure with the late payment interest calculator.

If you've made a mistake, say so and correct it. Don't edit and resend an invoice that's already been issued with the same number. The usual way is a credit note that cancels all or part of the original, then a new invoice if needed. That keeps your numbering and your records straight. If you're VAT registered, it keeps the VAT right too.

If you think they're wrong

Send your evidence, briefly, and say what you're asking for:

"Thanks for checking. The timesheet for w/c [DATE], signed by [NAME], shows 4 hours on Sunday (attached), at the Sunday rate in our email of [DATE]. Please pay the £1,000.00 that isn't in question by [DUE DATE], and the remaining £150.00 by [DATE]. If you still disagree, let me know what you'd accept and I'll consider it."

Inviting an offer isn't weakness. A quick compromise on a small amount often costs less than weeks of chasing.

If the client is a homeowner

Consumers have legal rights that matter in a dispute. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, a trader must perform a service with reasonable care and skill (section 49). If it isn't, section 54 gives the consumer the right to ask you to put it right (repeat performance) and, in some cases, a price reduction.

So if a homeowner reports a genuine defect, offering to come back and fix it is usually your best move. It's often what they want, and it puts you in a better position if things escalate. Our guide on chasing a homeowner for payment covers the rest.

If you can't agree

  1. Send a letter before claim setting out what's owed, why, and a deadline.
  2. Try mediation. GOV.UK says mediation, where an impartial person helps both sides reach an agreement, could be quicker and cheaper than court.
  3. Make a court claim. If you claim £10,000 or less and the other side disputes it, GOV.UK says you'll be told you must attend mediation, organised by the court and free. See taking an unpaid invoice to court.

Don't threaten bankruptcy or winding up over a genuinely disputed invoice. See why in our guide to statutory demands.

Preventing the next one

  • Agree rates, overtime and weekend rates in writing first. A rate card makes this easy.
  • Get hours signed off weekly, while everyone remembers the week.
  • Invoice weekly, so any dispute is about one week, not a month.
  • Describe each line clearly: date, site and what was done.
How BillMyWeek helps: each invoice lists the days, site, rate and overtime line by line, so it's clear what's being charged. Pro's timesheet (also in the 14-day free trial, then £1.99/month or £19.99/year) has an optional link for your client or foreman to approve the hours, no account needed. BillMyWeek doesn't make credit notes yet. You can try it without signing up.

Free: The UK Contractor's Cheat Sheet 2026/27

CIS rates, overtime maths, tax dates, mileage, VAT and late payment, on 2 pages. Keep it on your phone or print it for the van.

We'll email you the cheat sheet. Unsubscribe any time. Tips only if you tick the box. Privacy

Frequently asked questions

Does a client have to pay the part of an invoice they don't dispute?

It's reasonable to ask them to pay the undisputed part by the due date. For business clients, late payment interest can apply to an amount paid late.

Should I change an invoice after the client disputes it?

Not by editing the issued invoice. Issue a credit note for the wrong amount and, if needed, a new invoice.

What if a homeowner says my work is faulty?

Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 a service must be done with reasonable care and skill, and the customer can ask you to put it right. Offering to fix genuine defects is usually the best first step.

Is mediation free for small claims?

GOV.UK says that if you claim £10,000 or less and the defendant disputes it, you must attend mediation organised by the court, and the service is free.

Sources

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules and rates change, so check the linked GOV.UK pages for the current position.

Make this week's invoice in a minute

BillMyWeek fills in your days, day rate and overtime, takes CIS off labour if you need it, and gives you a clean PDF to send. 14 days free, then £1.99 a month or £19.99 a year. No card needed to start.

Try it free: make an invoice now, no sign-up Start your free trial

Free tools

Day rate calculatorDay rate to hourly, overtime and weekend ratesCIS deduction calculatorTake-home after 20%, 30% or 0% CISAnnual income calculatorDay rate to weekly, monthly and yearly incomeOvertime calculatorTime and a quarter, half and double timeTime and a half calculatorHourly and day rate at x1.5Overtime tax calculatorEstimate tax and NI on overtimeLate payment interest calculatorStatutory interest and fixed compensationVAT calculatorAdd or remove VAT, with the construction reverse chargeSelf-employed tax calculatorIncome Tax, Class 4 NI and take-home for 2026/27CIS refund calculatorEstimate your CIS tax refund or billMileage allowance calculatorHMRC 55p and 25p rates for 2026/27Markup and margin calculatorPrice materials and jobs, convert markup to marginHoliday pay calculator12.07% holiday pay and day rate time offFree quote generatorLabour and materials quote with VAT and CIS, saved as a PDFFree invoice chaserPayment reminder messages for text, WhatsApp and emailEtsy fee calculatorEtsy UK fees, VAT and profit per saleeBay fee calculatorPrivate and business seller fees and profitVinted tax checkerHobby or trading, HMRC reporting and taxSide hustle tax calculator£1,000 trading allowance and tax on top of a jobWorking from home expensesHMRC flat rates and 55p mileageDelivery driver tax calculatorMileage and tax for couriersAmazon seller fee calculatorReferral, plan and FBA feesRent a Room calculator£7,500 tax-free lodger incomeContractor's cheat sheet 2026/27CIS, overtime, tax dates, mileage, VAT and late payment on 2 pagesCIS cheat sheetOne-page PDF for subcontractorsIs my invoice legal? checkerCheck an invoice against GOV.UK requirementsFree invoice templatesInvoice, quote, CIS statement and day-rate templatesSample invoiceSee a finished weekly invoice PDF, no sign-up

Start a free BillMyWeek trial to turn your numbers into a ready-to-send invoice.